The Cookware LabRanked
Non-Toxic Cookware · Head-to-Head

Caraway vs. Our Place vs. Made In (2026): The Safety-First Comparison

Same Instagram feeds, very different materials. What each brand's cookware is actually made of, what each publishes to back its safety claims, and who should buy which.

Updated July 2026 · Based on each brand's own materials disclosures + Ecology Center nonstick research + state PFAS cookware laws

For safety-first buyers, Made In's uncoated 10-piece Stainless Clad set ($799) wins - bare 5-ply stainless has no coating to verify. Our Place's coating-free Titanium Always Pan Pro (from $135) is the best single pan. Caraway's ceramic 12-piece set ($445) is PFAS-free by brand claim only.

Quick answer
#CookwareMaterialPFASPriceVerdictLink
1Made In 10-Piece Stainless Clad SetUncoated 5-ply stainless, made in Italy5-ply stainless cladNone (uncoated)$749-$79910-pc setSafe by constructionBest for safety + a lifetime of usePrice
2Our Place Titanium Always Pan ProCoating-free titanium surface, tri-plyTitanium interior / aluminum core / stainless exteriorNone (uncoated)$135-$17910.6" pan, by size/saleSafe by constructionBest single pan of the three brandsPrice
3Caraway Cookware SetCeramic-coated aluminum, 4 pans + lids + storageSol-gel ceramic over aluminumNone claimed$44512-pc set (4 pans)Self-reportedBest-looking set; safety is brand-claimed, and coatings are consumablePrice

Verdict language is matched to the strength of the underlying evidence (verified → self-reported → avoid). See how we rank.

How we ranked these

We do not lab-test cookware, and none of these three brands has published complete independent lab reports we can rank numerically. This comparison aggregates each brand's own published materials disclosures (Made In, Caraway, Our Place), independent transparency reviews like Mamavation's ceramic cookware investigation, and the construction facts that need no lab at all. Full process: methodology.

The verdict ladder. Safe by construction = uncoated metal cooking surface; there is no coating for PFAS to hide in, so no claim is needed. Self-reported = the brand states its coating is PFAS-free but no named third party has published results. We rank construction over claims, which is why an uncoated pan outranks a $445 ceramic set on safety.

What we can't rank. We cannot tell you whose ceramic coating is "cleanest" - no comparable third-party dataset covers these brands - so we don't pretend to.

The picks, in detail
1.

Made In 10-Piece Stainless Clad Set

Safe by construction$749-$799 10-pc set

Made In's 10-piece Stainless Clad set ($799 direct, $749.99 at Crate & Barrel as of July 2026) is the only flagship set of the three with no coating anywhere: six 5-ply stainless pots and pans plus four lids, made in Italy, oven-safe far beyond any ceramic pan's rating. Uncoated stainless is PFAS-free by construction - there is simply no nonstick layer to test, verify, or wear out - which is why it takes the safety-first crown despite the highest sticker price. Amortized, the math flips: stainless clad routinely lasts decades, while ceramic coatings fade in 1-3 years. Honesty note: Made In also sells a separate ProCoat nonstick line using a conventional PTFE-family coating, and says so plainly - buy the Stainless Clad line, not the brand.

Check current price
2.

Our Place Titanium Always Pan Pro

Safe by construction$135-$179 10.6" pan, by size/sale

The Titanium Always Pan Pro (from $135) is Our Place's best safety story because it deletes the coating question: the cooking surface is textured titanium metal with no coating at all, made without PFAS by construction, rated to 1000°F, and covered by a lifetime warranty. That makes it the one Our Place product we can put above brand-claim status - unlike the classic ceramic Always Pan, whose Thermakind coating is self-reported PFAS-free with no published third-party results (Mamavation's transparency review flagged exactly this gap, along with nanoparticle disclosure). It is semi-nonstick, not Teflon-slick, and one pan is not a set. But if you want the Instagram-brand experience with the strongest materials answer, this is it - full breakdown in best titanium cookware.

Check current price
3.

Caraway Cookware Set

Self-reported$445 12-pc set (4 pans)

Caraway's flagship Cookware Set is $445 as of July 2026 (list $675) for four ceramic-coated pans, three lids, and its signature storage racks - the strongest design and unboxing experience of the three brands by a wide margin. On safety, Caraway markets the coating as free of PFAS, lead, and cadmium and describes it as third-party tested, and it is among the more forthcoming ceramic brands - but complete lab reports are not published for public review, so under our ladder that remains a brand-reported claim, the same tier as budget ceramic like Carote. The bigger honest caveat is lifespan: sol-gel ceramic is a consumable that typically fades within 1-3 years, so price it as a recurring cost, not a lifetime buy. Oven-safe to 550°F, no metal utensils.

Check current price

Materials, side by side

Caraway: sol-gel ceramic nonstick over aluminum, made in China; claims free of PFAS (including PTFE), lead, and cadmium; oven-safe to 550°F; hand-wash, no metal utensils. Our Place: the classic Always Pan line is the same category - self-reported PFAS-free ceramic over aluminum, oven-safe around 450°F - while the Titanium Always Pan Pro is a different animal entirely: uncoated titanium over tri-ply, 1000°F, metal-utensil and dishwasher safe. Made In: the Stainless Clad line is uncoated 5-ply stainless made in Italy - the only full set here with nothing coated - though the brand's separate ProCoat nonstick line is a conventional PTFE-family coating, disclosed openly. All three brands comply with the wave of state PFAS cookware laws led by Minnesota's Amara's Law for the lines compared on this page; only Made In's ProCoat line raises that flag, so within Made In, choose stainless.

What each brand actually publishes

Disclosure quality is where these brands separate. Made In publishes exact construction specs (ply counts, alloys, factories) and is candid that its nonstick line is conventional - the most matter-of-fact disclosure of the three, made easier because its flagship line has nothing to defend. Caraway makes the most detailed safety claims of the ceramic brands and references third-party testing, but does not post complete lab reports for public review. Our Place publishes the least test documentation - its ceramic coating's PFAS-free status is a marketing claim without published data, which Mamavation's review criticized alongside both brands' late disclosure of nanoparticles in ceramic coatings; the titanium pan sidesteps this by having no coating to document. None of the three has a published Ecology-Center-style independent test of current production. That absence is the honest headline of this comparison - and why construction, not claims, drives our ranking. More brands with real receipts: PFAS-free cookware brands.

Price math and who should buy which

Sticker prices (July 2026): Caraway set $445 for four pans with lids and storage (about $111 per pan); Made In $749-$799 for six pots and pans plus four lids (about $80 per lidded piece); Our Place $135-$179 for one do-most-things pan. Lifetime math favors the uncoated picks: ceramic coatings typically fade in 1-3 years, so a $445 Caraway set replaced twice costs more than the Made In set that is still going. Buy Caraway if you want the best-looking coordinated set, cook mostly at low-medium heat, and accept replacing coated pans as routine. Buy the Our Place titanium pan if you want one durable, coating-free pan under $200 and will learn a preheat habit. Buy Made In stainless if you want a full set you never think about again - the strongest safety-plus-longevity answer on this page. If all three stretch the budget, our safest non-toxic cookware guide covers uncoated picks from $25.

Frequently asked

Which is healthier: Caraway, Our Place, or Made In?

Made In's Stainless Clad line and Our Place's Titanium Always Pan Pro have the strongest safety position, because both cook on uncoated metal - there is no coating for PFAS to be in. Caraway's ceramic (and Our Place's classic ceramic Always Pan) are PFAS-free by brand claim, without published independent lab results; nothing published suggests a problem, but uncoated construction beats any claim.

Does Caraway publish third-party test results?

Caraway says its ceramic coating is third-party tested and free of PFAS, lead, and cadmium, and it makes more detailed claims than most ceramic brands - but complete lab reports are not posted for public review, so we classify Caraway as brand-reported rather than independently verified. That is a documentation gap, not an accusation.

Is Made In cookware PFAS-free?

Made In's Stainless Clad line is PFAS-free by construction - bare 5-ply stainless steel has no coating at all. The brand's separate ProCoat nonstick line uses a conventional PTFE-family coating, which Made In discloses openly. So check the line, not the brand: for a PFAS-free kitchen, buy Made In's stainless (or carbon steel), not its nonstick.

Which lasts longer, Caraway or Made In?

Made In's stainless, by years - uncoated stainless clad routinely lasts decades, while sol-gel ceramic coatings like Caraway's typically lose their nonstick within 1-3 years even with careful use. Our Place's titanium pan also has no coating to wear out and carries a lifetime warranty. Treat any ceramic-coated pan as a consumable when comparing prices.

Is the Always Pan worth it compared to Caraway?

The ceramic Always Pan and Caraway's fry/sauté pans are the same material category with the same trade-offs, so choose on shape and price - Caraway's higher 550°F oven rating and lid options against the Always Pan's built-in steamer and spatula. If safety evidence is the tiebreaker, skip both ceramics and get the Titanium Always Pan Pro, which is coating-free by construction.

Are Caraway and Our Place pans made in China?

Yes - both brands manufacture their ceramic cookware in China, while Made In's stainless clad is made in Italy. Country of origin is not a safety verdict: coating chemistry and published test data matter far more than geography, which is exactly where these brands differ.

Sources
Keep reading